Attorney general blocks Netanyahu plan to name Amir Ohana a minister
Israel's government legal adviser says outgoing Knesset Speaker Amir Ohana cannot join the transitional cabinet without parliamentary approval.

Benjamin Netanyahu. צילום ארכיון: Avi Ohayon, CC BY-SA 3.0, מתוך ויקישיתוף.
הכתבה המלאה עדיין לא נכתבה בעברית, ולכן היא מובאת כאן באנגלית.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has been told he may not appoint Amir Ohana, the outgoing speaker of the Knesset, as a government minister unless the Knesset approves the move. Ynet reported that Netanyahu had intended to give Ohana the strategic affairs portfolio in the transitional government, and that Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara stopped the plan, ruling that the step requires the Knesset's consent.
According to Ynet, the attorney general's position is that a member of the Knesset can be made a minister without a parliamentary vote only where a "governmental vacuum" has arisen, and that this is not such a case. Ynet described the intended appointment as a "consolation prize" for Ohana. The political commentator Amit Segal reported the same message on his Telegram channel, framing it as the attorney general telling Netanyahu directly that the appointment was not permitted without Knesset approval.
Who issued the opinion
The reports differ on which official delivered the ruling. Ynet, Amit Segal and the Hebrew news channel News.co.il attribute it to the attorney general herself. The Times of Israel attributed the position to a deputy attorney general. Opinions on government matters are often signed by deputies acting within the attorney general's office, but the reports available here do not settle which official wrote this one.
A second discrepancy concerns which body must give its approval. A short alert on the Ynet alerts Telegram channel quoted the attorney general as saying that approval of the government was required, while the fuller Ynet article and the other three reports all refer to approval by the Knesset. Under Israeli law, adding a minister to a sitting government ordinarily involves both a cabinet decision and a vote in the Knesset, which may explain the different wording, though none of the reports addresses the point.
The attorney general's role
Israel's attorney general serves as the government's chief legal adviser and heads the state's legal system on the executive side. The office's interpretation of the law is generally treated as binding on ministers, and the government typically cannot act against it without risking a challenge before the High Court of Justice. Gali Baharav-Miara has held the post through Netanyahu's current term and has repeatedly clashed with his government over legal questions, which places this opinion within a long-running dispute between the prime minister and the legal adviser's office.
מייל ביום שבו תושבע הממשלה החדשה.
המגעים להרכבת הקואליציה יכולים להימשך שבועות. כשהממשלה החדשה מושבעת, מערכת החדשות של Israel.com שולחת במייל מי עומד בראשה, אילו מפלגות נכללות בה ומי קיבל איזה תיק, ואחר כך את המייל של יום שישי בכל שבוע. חינם, וההסרה בלחיצה אחת.
רשימה אחת, הסרה בלחיצה. הפרטים במדיניות הפרטיות שלנו.
What a transitional government is
Ynet described the cabinet into which Ohana was to be appointed as a transitional government. In Israel, an outgoing government continues to run the country until a new coalition is formed and sworn in by the Knesset. Legal advisers have long held that such governments should act with restraint, particularly on appointments, because they do not have a renewed mandate from parliament. The attorney general's distinction, as reported by Ynet, between ordinary appointments and those needed to fill a genuine governmental vacuum reflects that approach: a transitional government may act where something would otherwise be left without anyone in charge, but should otherwise seek the Knesset's backing.
Amir Ohana and the strategic affairs portfolio
Amir Ohana is a senior member of Netanyahu's Likud party and has served as speaker of the Knesset, Israel's parliament. Ynet and News.co.il describe him as the outgoing speaker, and Ynet called the planned ministerial post a consolation prize, suggesting it was meant to give him a role as he leaves the speaker's chair. Before becoming speaker, Ohana held cabinet posts in earlier Netanyahu governments. The Ynet alerts channel reported that the push to appoint him came from within Likud.

צילום ארכיון
הכתבה הבאה פוליטיקה
הכנסת תצביע על החלפת היו"ר אוחנה, אחרי ש-67 ח"כים חתמו על בקשה
The Ministry of Strategic Affairs is a government portfolio that has at various times handled policy on threats to Israel abroad. Its responsibilities and its status as a standalone ministry have changed between governments, and the reports do not describe what the post would involve for Ohana.
What the reports do not say
None of the reports carries a response from Netanyahu, Ohana or Likud, and none says whether the prime minister intends to bring the appointment to a Knesset vote, drop it, or contest the legal opinion. The text of the opinion has not been published in the material, so the reasoning behind the governmental vacuum test is known only through Ynet's summary. It also remains unclear whether the ruling came from the attorney general or one of her deputies, and whether government approval, Knesset approval or both are being cited as the requirement.
להמשך קריאה
למדור פוליטיקה →
צילום ארכיון
פוליטיקה
אוחנה פתח את הכנסת העשרים ושש בקריאה לאחדות ובמסר על חמאס

צילום ארכיון
בחירות
נתניהו אמר בכנסת שתוצאות הבחירות אינן מה שרצה וקרא לאחדות

צילום ארכיון
משפט ופלילים
נתניהו סיים להעיד בתביעת לשון הרע, כרמון סירב להתנצל ויעלה לדוכן העדים

צילום ארכיון
בחירות
גוש איזנקוט יחליף את יו"ר הכנסת אוחנה ויקים ועדה לביטול חוקי המהפכה המשפטית
מקורות וקריאה נוספת
פתחנו ובדקנו כל קישור כאן בזמן כתיבת העמוד. הודעות רשמיות מסומנות ככאלה: זו הגרסה של הגורם עצמו, לא גרסה עצמאית.
- כתבותamitsegalt.meAmit Segal
- כתבותyediothynet.co.ilYnet
- כתבותyediotht.meYnet alerts
- כתבותtoitimesofisrael.comThe Times of Israel
- כתבותnewssilt.meNews.co.il
איך בדקנו את זה
Four organisations (Ynet, The Times of Israel, News.co.il and commentator Amit Segal) reported the legal opinion; the governmental vacuum reasoning comes from Ynet alone. Reports differ on whether the attorney general or a deputy issued it, and one Ynet alert cites government rather than Knesset approval.
מדיניות המקורות והתיקונים שלנו →השבוע בישראל, במייל אחד
הכתבות החשובות, עם מקורות ואחרי בדיקה של מערכת Israel.com. חינם, פעם בשבוע, ואפשר להפסיק בלחיצה אחת.
רשימה אחת, הסרה בלחיצה. הפרטים במדיניות הפרטיות שלנו.
Israel.com נשאר חינמי בזכות קוראים כמוך.
מערכת החדשות של Israel.com בודקת כל ידיעה מול המקורות שלה ומפרסמת אותה בחינם. אם הידיעה עזרה לך, תמיכה בכל סכום שומרת גם את הבאה חינמית.
תשלום אחד, בלי הרשמה. סכום אחרתמיכה חודשית
הכתבות האחרונות

איור

צילום ארכיון

איור

צילום ארכיון

צילום ארכיון

איור