Haredi protesters clash with Jerusalem police on Bar-Ilan Street
Police moved to disperse ultra-Orthodox protesters blocking Jerusalem roads, as Israeli outlets gave differing accounts of what the Bar-Ilan Street protest was about.

איור שנוצר בבינה מלאכותית, לא צילום של האירועים.
עדכון אחד מאז הפרסום
- News.co.il says the Bar-Ilan protest targeted light rail works; police dispersed it after calls to clear were ignored.
הכתבה הזאת מתעדכנת בזמן שהאירוע מתפתח. הטקסט המוקדם נשמר מתחת לעדכונים ולא נכתב מחדש, כך שמה שהעמוד אמר בכל שלב עדיין נמצא בו.
הכתבה המלאה עדיין לא נכתבה בעברית, ולכן היא מובאת כאן באנגלית.
Update, 23 November, 00:07 Israel time
A second outlet has given a different reason for the disturbance on Bar-Ilan Street. News.co.il reported that the extremist Haredi protest there was directed against construction work on the light rail, not against the arrest of deserters as earlier accounts said. The other reports on the page linked the day's protests to the detention of deserters. The reports do not settle which motive applied, or whether more than one grievance was involved.
News.co.il also gave more detail on the police response. According to the outlet, regular police officers were joined by the Border Police and by Yasam, a police special patrol unit often used for riot control. It said roads were blocked and property and infrastructure were damaged. Officers began dispersing the gathering only after protesters ignored calls to clear the area, the outlet reported, and it posted footage from the scene.
The Jerusalem Post published police footage showing officers clashing with Haredi demonstrators who were blocking Bar-Ilan Street. The paper described the clashes as following widespread unrest across Jerusalem during the day.
Neither new report gives figures for injuries, arrests or the number of protesters, and neither says what dispersal methods officers used.
The story as first reported
Ultra-Orthodox protesters angry at the arrest of army deserters disrupted traffic in Jerusalem, blocking the city's light rail, Ynet reported. According to the outlet, the demonstration took place in the area of Shivtei Israel Street and Bar-Lev Road, and the protest forced changes to light rail routes. Ynet described the demonstrators as extremist Haredim.
השבוע בישראל בחמש ידיעות, בכל יום שישי
מקורות ובדיקה של מערכת Israel.com, עם זמני השבת. חינם, ואפשר להפסיק בלחיצה אחת.
רשימה אחת, הסרה בלחיצה. הפרטים במדיניות הפרטיות שלנו.
Later in the day, a Ynet news alert said Haredim were protesting the arrest of a deserter in the city and that a Border Police vehicle had been attacked. N12 correspondent Or Ravid reported that police were working to break up a disturbance on Bar-Ilan Street, where, he wrote, rioters were blocking roads and damaging infrastructure. Police had begun using force and crowd dispersal measures, according to the same report, which carried footage credited to the police spokesperson's unit.
Who was protesting, and why
Haredi is the Hebrew term for ultra-Orthodox Jews, a community that places full-time religious study at the centre of life for many men. Military service for Haredi men has been one of the most contested issues in Israeli public life for decades. Many young men from the community do not report for duty when called up, and those who fail to respond to draft orders can be classed by the army as deserters and detained.

איור
הכתבה הבאה משפט ופלילים
המשטרה פיזרה הפגנת חרדים בתוואי הרכבת הקלה בירושלים, אדם אחד נעצר
Arrests of such men have repeatedly drawn street protests from parts of the Haredi community, often from its more hardline factions, which reject any form of enlistment. Demonstrations of this kind typically involve blocking major roads and junctions in Jerusalem and other cities with large Haredi populations. The reports describe this protest as a response to the detention of deserters, but do not name the person or people arrested or say where they were held.
Where it happened
The locations named in the reports are main routes through the city. Shivtei Israel Street runs along the edge of central Jerusalem near the walls of the Old City and carries the light rail, the city's tram network. Bar-Lev Road is a major north-south artery, and Bar-Ilan Street runs through northern Jerusalem close to several predominantly Haredi neighbourhoods. Blocking any of these roads can quickly spread congestion across the city, and blocking the light rail cuts one of Jerusalem's busiest public transport lines.
The Border Police
Ynet's alert referred to a vehicle belonging to the Border Police, known in Hebrew by the acronym Magav. Despite its name, the Border Police is a branch of the Israel Police rather than of the army, and its units are frequently deployed for crowd control and public order operations in Jerusalem. The alert did not say who was inside the vehicle, whether anyone was hurt, or how it was attacked.
Differences between the reports
The accounts describe protest activity at different places and at different times of day. Ynet's article placed the light rail blockage at Shivtei Israel and Bar-Lev, while N12's report from later in the day concerned Bar-Ilan Street. Ynet's article spoke of arrests of deserters in the plural, while its alert referred to the arrest of a single deserter. The reports do not make clear whether these were one continuous demonstration that moved through the city or separate protests on the same day.
What the reports do not say
None of the reports gives a number of protesters, says whether anyone was injured, or says whether police made any arrests. They do not describe what force or dispersal measures police used, what infrastructure was damaged, or how long the light rail disruption lasted. No statement from the army about the detention that prompted the protest, and no response from Haredi community leaders, appears in the material.

xiquinhosilva / CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons
להמשך קריאה
למדור משפט ופלילים →
צילום ארכיון
יהדות
מפגינים חרדים חסמו לזמן קצר את רכבו של מאיר פרוש בירושלים

איור
משפט ופלילים
מפקד מחוז ירושלים מתחייב לתפוס את רוצח הילד Qusai al-Julani בשועפאט

צילום ארכיון
ביטחון
נתניהו אירח בירושלים את ראש ממשלת צ'כיה באביש ואמר שגם אירופה היא יעד של איראן

איור
משפט ופלילים
גבר כבן 30 נורה למוות ברחוב אחילוף ביפו, המשטרה חוקרת
מקורות וקריאה נוספת
פתחנו ובדקנו כל קישור כאן בזמן כתיבת העמוד. הודעות רשמיות מסומנות ככאלה: זו הגרסה של הגורם עצמו, לא גרסה עצמאית.
- כתבותyediothynet.co.ilYnet
- כתבותyediotht.meYnet alerts
- כתבותkeshett.meN12
- כתבותjpostjpost.comThe Jerusalem Post
- כתבותnewssilt.meNews.co.il
איך בדקנו את זה
Several outlets and police footage confirm clashes and dispersal on Bar-Ilan Street. The protest's motive is disputed: Ynet cites deserter arrests, while News.co.il alone cites light rail construction work.
מדיניות המקורות והתיקונים שלנו →השבוע בישראל, במייל אחד
הכתבות החשובות, עם מקורות ואחרי בדיקה של מערכת Israel.com. חינם, פעם בשבוע, ואפשר להפסיק בלחיצה אחת.
רשימה אחת, הסרה בלחיצה. הפרטים במדיניות הפרטיות שלנו.
הכתבות האחרונות

צילום ארכיון

איור

איור

צילום ארכיון

צילום ארכיון

איור