דילוג לתוכן הראשי

IDF chief Zamir at Ben-Gurion memorial: the army is short of combat soldiers

Lt. Gen. Eyal Zamir said the IDF must grow and spread the burden more evenly, as talks over ultra-Orthodox conscription continue in the background.

מערכת Israel.com··3 דקות קריאה·
שיתוף
Eyal Zamir in 2025

הכתבה המלאה עדיין לא נכתבה בעברית, ולכן היא מובאת כאן באנגלית.

The chief of staff of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), Lieutenant General Eyal Zamir, told a seminar and memorial ceremony for David Ben-Gurion that the army does not have enough combat soldiers and needs to expand. According to a statement released by the IDF spokesperson, Zamir tied the shortage to Ben-Gurion's idea of a "People's Army", saying the concept rests first of all on an operational requirement and that "the IDF is short of combat troops." He added that this situation "has not changed."

Zamir also argued that widening the circle of those who serve would let the operational load be shared more evenly across Israeli society, and would above all bring significant relief to reservists, N12 reported, citing its correspondent Nitzan Shapira. The IDF statement says he went on to describe a national need and a sense of responsibility alongside the operational one, though the published excerpt cuts off before that point is completed.

Who spoke, and where

The chief of the general staff, known in Hebrew by the acronym Ramatkal, is the most senior officer in the IDF and commands all branches of the military. Zamir holds the rank of lieutenant general, the highest in the Israeli army.

The occasion was a seminar and ceremony held in memory of David Ben-Gurion, Israel's founding prime minister, who oversaw the creation of the IDF. Zamir used the setting to invoke one of the founding principles associated with Ben-Gurion: the "People's Army", in Hebrew tzva ha'am. The phrase describes a military built on broad national conscription, drawing soldiers from across society rather than relying on a professional or volunteer force.

The political backdrop: a conscription law

Several Hebrew-language outlets placed the remarks in the context of the ongoing dispute over drafting ultra-Orthodox men, known as Haredim, into the army. Exemptions and deferrals for Haredi yeshiva students have long been one of the most contested questions in Israeli politics, and any change requires legislation, usually referred to as a conscription or draft law.

השבוע בישראל בחמש ידיעות, בכל יום שישי

מקורות ובדיקה של מערכת Israel.com, עם זמני השבת. חינם, ואפשר להפסיק בלחיצה אחת.

רשימה אחת, הסרה בלחיצה. הפרטים במדיניות הפרטיות שלנו.

Ynet reported that Zamir spoke against the background of negotiations between Eisenkot and the Haredim, and following a remark by Avigdor Liberman, whom the site described as the temporary chairman of the Knesset's Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee. Liberman, according to Ynet, had spoken of a conscription law that would be acceptable both to the chief of staff and to Rabbi Landau. News.co.il gave a similar account, saying Liberman had described the need for a draft law that would satisfy both Zamir and Rabbi Landau.

The Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee is the parliamentary body that oversees the military and security services, and it is the forum where draft legislation is typically debated in detail. Rabbi Landau, as referred to in these reports, is a figure in the Haredi community whose approval Liberman framed as necessary for any law to pass alongside the army's. Political commentator Amit Segal also framed the speech as coming amid contacts with the Haredim.

Zamir himself, in the excerpts published by the IDF and by the Hebrew outlets, did not mention the Haredi community, the negotiations, Liberman or any specific piece of legislation. The link between his remarks and the draft talks is drawn by the outlets reporting on the speech, not stated in his words.

Why reservists feature in the argument

Israel's military depends heavily on reservists, citizens who have completed compulsory service and are called back for duty. Zamir's point, as reported by N12 and News.co.il, was that a larger pool of conscripts would ease the load carried by those reservists. Ynet's alert summarised the message in a single line: the IDF must expand, and combat soldiers are lacking.

How the reports differ

The reports agree on the substance of what Zamir said. They differ in how they describe the surrounding politics. Ynet refers specifically to negotiations involving Eisenkot, while Amit Segal speaks more generally of contacts with the Haredim. News.co.il and Ynet both link the speech to Liberman's comment, while the IDF's own statement presents it without political framing. None of the reports describes the state of the talks in detail.

What the reports do not say

The reports do not give the size of the combat soldier shortage or any figure for how many additional troops the IDF says it needs. They do not report any response from Haredi leaders, from Rabbi Landau, from Eisenkot or from Liberman to Zamir's remarks. Nor do they say where the conscription negotiations currently stand or whether a draft bill has been tabled. The IDF's published excerpt also ends mid-sentence, so the full text of Zamir's remarks on national responsibility has not been reported.

למדור לזכרם →
נושאיםidfconscriptionharedimeyal zamir

מקורות וקריאה נוספת

פתחנו ובדקנו כל קישור כאן בזמן כתיבת העמוד. הודעות רשמיות מסומנות ככאלה: זו הגרסה של הגורם עצמו, לא גרסה עצמאית.

  1. רשמיidft.me
    IDF spokesperson
  2. כתבותyediothynet.co.il
    Ynet
  3. כתבותyediotht.me
    Ynet alerts
  4. כתבותamitsegalt.me
    Amit Segal
  5. כתבותnewssilt.me
    News.co.il
  6. כתבותkeshett.me
    N12

איך בדקנו את זה

Zamir's remarks are drawn from the IDF spokesperson's statement and were reported consistently by N12, Ynet, News.co.il and Amit Segal. The link to Haredi draft negotiations and Liberman's comment comes from those outlets, not from Zamir's own words.

מדיניות המקורות והתיקונים שלנו →

השבוע בישראל, במייל אחד

הכתבות החשובות, עם מקורות ואחרי בדיקה של מערכת Israel.com. חינם, פעם בשבוע, ואפשר להפסיק בלחיצה אחת.

רשימה אחת, הסרה בלחיצה. הפרטים במדיניות הפרטיות שלנו.

הכתבות האחרונות

← כל החדשות

שותףמקום פנוי לשותף במדור חדשות3,765 כניסות מגוגל ב-⁠28 ימים. החל מ-‏290 ‏₪ לחודש.