דילוג לתוכן הראשי

Lebanese media say Israeli troops detained two brothers in Shebaa raid

Lebanon's state news agency says soldiers searched a family home near Shebaa overnight and took two brothers away; the Israeli military has not commented.

מערכת Israel.com··3 דקות קריאה·
שיתוף
Illustration of tan stone village houses on a rocky slope near Shebaa, with the Mount Hermon ridge behind under overcast dawn light

הכתבה המלאה עדיין לא נכתבה בעברית, ולכן היא מובאת כאן באנגלית.

Israeli soldiers detained two Lebanese brothers during an overnight raid on their home near the village of Shebaa in southern Lebanon, according to Lebanese media reports relayed by Israeli outlets on Monday morning. Emanuel Fabian, military correspondent for the Times of Israel, wrote that Lebanon's National News Agency described troops entering and searching the house, "ransacking its contents and damaging belongings," and then leaving the area with both men.

The Israel Defense Forces (IDF), the country's military, had not responded to the reports at the time they were published, both Fabian and the Hebrew news channel News.co.il noted. The Israeli channel Abu Ali Express, citing Lebanese sources, identified the two as Mohammed and Asaad Hamdan and said they are brothers of Maher Hamdan, a man it said the IDF arrested more than a year ago and who remains in custody in Israel.

מה המקורות פרסמו

Israeli troops apprehended two Lebanese men on the outskirts of the southern town of Shebaa overnight, according to Lebanese media. Lebanon's National News Agency reports that the troops raided and searched the home of the two men, who are brothers, "ransacking its contents and Show more

וידאו מאת Emanuel Fabian on X. אפשר להקיש כדי לנגן. שום דבר ממנו לא מוצג עד אז.
לצפייה ב-X
פורסם על ידי Emanuel Fabian on X ב-X. הפוסט לא אומת על ידי Israel.com.

מהשטח

פורסם על ידי Ynetnews ב-X. הפוסט אינו מקור של הכתבה הזאת, ולא אומת על ידי Israel.com.

Where Shebaa is

Shebaa is a village in southern Lebanon close to the area Israelis call Har Dov, or Mount Dov, a sector near the point where the borders of Israel, Lebanon and Syria meet. Internationally the wider area is often referred to as the Shebaa Farms, and its status is disputed. Both Abu Ali Express and News.co.il placed the raid in the Har Dov sector, while Fabian's account, drawing on Lebanese media, located it on the outskirts of the town.

Who reported what

Every account of the detentions available so far traces back to Lebanese reporting. The most detailed version comes from the National News Agency, Lebanon's official state news service, as summarised by Fabian in English. It says the soldiers searched the home of the two men, caused damage inside, took the brothers and withdrew.

Abu Ali Express, a Telegram channel that follows Arabic-language media, added the family details: the names of the two men, the earlier arrest of a third brother, and the claim that the pair were taken into Israeli territory. News.co.il, which called the operation unusual, also said the family name was Hamdan and that another brother had previously been detained in the same area, though it did not name him.

השבוע בישראל בחמש ידיעות, בכל יום שישי

מקורות ובדיקה של מערכת Israel.com, עם זמני השבת. חינם, ואפשר להפסיק בלחיצה אחת.

רשימה אחת, הסרה בלחיצה. הפרטים במדיניות הפרטיות שלנו.

Differences in the accounts

The reports diverge in wording and detail. Israeli outlets writing in their own voice used terms such as apprehended, detained or arrested. Abu Ali Express said Lebanese sources described the men as having been "kidnapped", and the channel put that word in quotation marks. Only Abu Ali Express stated that the brothers were moved into Israel; the other reports said only that they were taken away. The channel also added a brief sardonic comment about a family reunion, which is its own framing rather than part of any Lebanese report.

Fabian's report describes the location as the edge of Shebaa, while Ynet and News.co.il said forces entered a house in the village itself. These may describe the same place in different terms, but the reports do not resolve the point.

A separate strike the same night

The Lebanese reports emerged alongside a separate Israeli operation. Ynet reported that the Israeli Air Force carried out a strike deep inside Lebanon, in the Beqaa Valley, which it said was the first bombing there in a long time. According to the IDF, as quoted by Ynet, the target was a weapons shipment from Syria intended for Hezbollah, the Iran-backed Lebanese armed group. Ynet mentioned the Shebaa detentions in the same item as a parallel development reported from Lebanon. None of the reports links the two events, and none suggests the detentions were connected to the strike.

Earlier detention in the family

According to Abu Ali Express, the brothers' sibling Maher Hamdan was arrested by the IDF more than a year ago and is still being held in Israel. The channel did not say on what grounds he was detained, and News.co.il referred only to an earlier arrest of another brother in the area. No report gives the circumstances of that earlier arrest or any charges.

What the reports do not say

The IDF has not confirmed that its forces carried out the raid or explained why the two men were detained, and no report gives a reason. It is not known where the brothers are being held, whether they face any charges, or whether Israel's account of the night will match the description given by Lebanon's National News Agency. The claim that the men were taken into Israeli territory rests on a single channel citing unnamed Lebanese sources.

למדור ביטחון →
נושאיםlebanonidfshebaahezbollah

מקורות וקריאה נוספת

פתחנו ובדקנו כל קישור כאן בזמן כתיבת העמוד. הודעות רשמיות מסומנות ככאלה: זו הגרסה של הגורם עצמו, לא גרסה עצמאית.

  1. כתבותyediothynet.co.il
    Ynet
  2. כתבותtoit.me
    Emanuel Fabian, Times of Israel military correspondent
  3. כתבותabualiexpresst.me
    Abu Ali Express
  4. כתבותtoix.com
    Emanuel Fabian on X
  5. כתבותnewssilt.me
    News.co.il

איך בדקנו את זה

The detentions were reported by Ynet, Times of Israel correspondent Emanuel Fabian, Abu Ali Express and News.co.il, all citing Lebanese media; the IDF has not confirmed them. The men's names and the claim they were taken into Israel come from Abu Ali Express alone.

מדיניות המקורות והתיקונים שלנו →

השבוע בישראל, במייל אחד

הכתבות החשובות, עם מקורות ואחרי בדיקה של מערכת Israel.com. חינם, פעם בשבוע, ואפשר להפסיק בלחיצה אחת.

רשימה אחת, הסרה בלחיצה. הפרטים במדיניות הפרטיות שלנו.

הכתבות האחרונות

← כל החדשות

שותףמקום פנוי לשותף במדור חדשות3,765 כניסות מגוגל ב-⁠28 ימים. החל מ-‏290 ‏₪ לחודש.