Three bus inspectors arrested after passenger dragged off bus in Tirat Carmel
Police detained three public transport inspectors filmed forcibly removing a passenger, and Transport Minister Miri Regev has moved to have them dismissed.

איור שנוצר בבינה מלאכותית, לא צילום של האירועים.
הכתבה המלאה עדיין לא נכתבה בעברית, ולכן היא מובאת כאן באנגלית.
Police have arrested three public transport inspectors for questioning on suspicion of assaulting a passenger on a bus in Tirat Carmel, in northern Israel. Ynet reported that the passenger, who had boarded the bus in the town, filed a complaint with police after the inspectors were captured on video pulling him off the bus by force. According to Ynet, the confrontation began with a dispute over validating his fare, and in the footage one of the inspectors is seen gripping the man by the neck.
Egged, the bus operator, told Ynet that the incident would be looked into. Later the same day, Transport Minister Miri Regev intervened. N12 reported, citing its correspondent Dean Fisher, that Regev said she had instructed the head of the National Public Transport Authority to call those involved to a hearing ahead of dismissal, and to demand that a complaint be lodged with the Israel Police against the attackers.
What the video is reported to show
The account of the incident so far rests on Ynet's report, which carried the footage. In Ynet's description, three inspectors drag the passenger from the bus, with one holding him around the neck. Ynet said the argument that preceded the removal concerned the validation of the trip, known in Hebrew as tikuf. On Israeli buses, passengers are expected to validate their fare with a payment card or app when they board, and inspectors check that each rider has done so. A passenger found travelling without a validated fare can be fined.
Ynet did not report the passenger's name, his condition, or whether he needed medical treatment. It also did not report the inspectors' account of what happened.
Who the minister instructed
The National Public Transport Authority is the body within the Transport Ministry responsible for regulating and overseeing bus and rail services across the country, including the companies that operate routes under government contracts. Regev's instruction was directed at the authority's director, according to N12.
השבוע בישראל בחמש ידיעות, בכל יום שישי
מקורות ובדיקה של מערכת Israel.com, עם זמני השבת. חינם, ואפשר להפסיק בלחיצה אחת.
רשימה אחת, הסרה בלחיצה. הפרטים במדיניות הפרטיות שלנו.
A separate alert from Ynet framed the minister's position more starkly. According to the Ynet alert, Regev called for immediate action to fire the inspectors suspected of assaulting the passenger. The N12 account describes a hearing process that comes before any dismissal, while the Ynet alert headline speaks of acting at once to fire them. The two reports do not necessarily conflict, since in Israel a hearing is generally a step required before an employee can be let go, but they emphasise different things, and neither report gives the full text of the minister's statement.
The police complaint
One detail in the reports may puzzle readers. Ynet said the passenger had already complained to police and that the inspectors had been detained for questioning. N12 reported that Regev also wanted the authority to file a complaint with police against those involved. The reports do not explain whether this would be a second complaint, made in the name of the authority or the operator, alongside the passenger's own, or how it relates to the investigation already under way.
Where Tirat Carmel is
Tirat Carmel is a small city on the coastal side of Mount Carmel, just south of Haifa. Its bus services link it to the Haifa metropolitan area. The reports do not identify the bus line or the route on which the incident took place.
What the reports do not say
- Who employs the inspectors. Egged commented on the incident, but none of the reports states whether the three work for Egged, for another contractor, or directly for a public body.
- Whether the passenger had in fact failed to validate his fare, and what each side said during the argument.
- Whether the passenger was injured.
- Any response from the inspectors or their representatives.
- Whether police have released the three, sought to extend their detention, or announced any charges.
- The outcome of Egged's own review, which the company said would take place.

יעקב / CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons
אנשים בכתבה: מירי רגב
להמשך קריאה
למדור משפט ופלילים →
איור
משפט ופלילים
העליון הורה על משפט חוזר לגינקולוג שהורשע באונס, בשל טעות של שופטיו

איור
משפט ופלילים
בן 23 נפצע קשה מפציעות חודרות באירוע אלים בסכנין

איור
משפט ופלילים
בית הדין בהאג קבע כי מיאנמר ביצעה רצח עם נגד הרוהינגה

איור
משפט ופלילים
ארבעה חשודים נעצרו ברצח גבר בשנות השבעים לחייו בערערה
מקורות וקריאה נוספת
פתחנו ובדקנו כל קישור כאן בזמן כתיבת העמוד. הודעות רשמיות מסומנות ככאלה: זו הגרסה של הגורם עצמו, לא גרסה עצמאית.
- כתבותyediothynet.co.ilYnet
- כתבותyediotht.meYnet alerts
- כתבותkeshett.meN12
איך בדקנו את זה
The arrest and the video are reported by Ynet; Egged's response comes from Ynet's report. Regev's instruction is reported by both N12 and a Ynet alert, which word her demand differently. We have not seen the footage or independently verified the account.
מדיניות המקורות והתיקונים שלנו →השבוע בישראל, במייל אחד
הכתבות החשובות, עם מקורות ואחרי בדיקה של מערכת Israel.com. חינם, פעם בשבוע, ואפשר להפסיק בלחיצה אחת.
רשימה אחת, הסרה בלחיצה. הפרטים במדיניות הפרטיות שלנו.
הכתבות האחרונות

איור

איור

צילום ארכיון

איור

צילום ארכיון

איור