Knesset legal adviser says Gilad Kariv's committee should not handle AG bill
The Knesset's legal adviser told MK Gilad Kariv that a bill undoing changes to the attorney general's powers belongs in a panel he does not chair, citing a conflict of interest.

Gilad Kariv. File photo by Rami Zarnegar, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
The legal adviser to the Knesset, Israel's parliament, has told opposition lawmaker Gilad Kariv that a bill to reverse recent changes to the attorney general's powers should be taken out of the committee he chairs and debated elsewhere, because of a conflict of interest. The Times of Israel reported that the adviser said the bill must be removed from the panel Kariv leads.
According to journalist Amit Segal, who first reported the exchange on his Telegram channel, the adviser told Kariv it was not sufficient for him simply to step back from running the sessions on the bill. She called instead for the legislation to be transferred to a different committee that he does not head, in order to reduce what Segal described as a concern about a lever of pressure. N12, a major Israeli television news outlet, relayed Segal's account in the same terms, and Ynet carried a brief alert saying the adviser wanted the bill debated in a committee that Kariv does not lead.
Why a conflict of interest was raised
The reports tie the adviser's position to Kariv's own legal situation. Segal wrote that Kariv is suspected of leaking a classified document and is waiting for the attorney general to decide on his case. The concern, as Segal framed it, is that a lawmaker whose fate rests partly with the attorney general should not be steering legislation that concerns that same official's powers.
Segal also wrote that the adviser addressed Kariv after Segal's own earlier publication on the matter. The material available does not describe what that earlier publication contained, and the other outlets did not add detail about the suspicion against Kariv beyond what Segal wrote.
The attorney general and the Knesset legal adviser
Two different legal officials appear in this story, and international readers can easily confuse them. In Israel the attorney general serves as the government's chief legal adviser and also heads the public prosecution, which means the office has a say in whether criminal cases go forward, including cases involving public figures. Hebrew reports refer to the current officeholder with the feminine title, indicating that a woman holds the post.
Get an email the day Israel has a new government.
Coalition talks can take weeks. When a government is sworn in, Israel.com's newsroom emails who leads it, which parties are in and who got which ministry, then the Friday email each week. Free, and one click unsubscribes.
One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.
The Knesset legal adviser is a separate official who advises parliament itself: its committees, its procedures and its members. Her role includes flagging when a committee process may be legally or ethically compromised. The Hebrew reports also use a feminine title for her. Her guidance on how the Knesset handles a bill is advice to the institution rather than a court ruling, and the reports do not say whether it is binding in this case.
The bill at the centre of the dispute
The legislation in question would repeal earlier changes to the attorney general's authority. Outlets described those earlier changes differently. The Times of Israel referred neutrally to changes to the attorney general's powers, while the Hebrew alerts from Ynet and from Segal described the original measure as a law to weaken the attorney general or her standing. The reports do not set out what those changes were, when they passed or who sponsored the repeal bill.

Illustration
Next story Government
Netanyahu meets Smotrich, Ben Gvir before Likud talks with Yashar
Knesset committees in Israel do much of the detailed work on legislation. A bill is typically sent to a committee between readings, where members debate it, hear from officials and amend the text before it returns to the full chamber. The chair of a committee controls the agenda and the pace of those sessions, which is why the identity of the chair can matter to a bill's prospects. The reports do not name the committee Kariv chairs or the committee the adviser has in mind as an alternative.
What the reports do not say
None of the reports carries a response from Kariv, so it is not known whether he accepts the adviser's position or intends to contest it. The suspicion that he leaked a classified document is reported only by Segal, without detail on the document or the investigation, and no other outlet independently describes it. The reports also do not say which committee would take the bill, who decides on a transfer, or when the attorney general is expected to rule on Kariv's case.
People in this story: Gilad Kariv, Amit Segal
Read next
All government →
Illustration
Government
Chikli confirms he sent post attacking bereaved MK Shapira, does not apologise

File photo
Government
Likud sets out its terms for a national unity government with Netanyahu

File photo
Government
Likud sets conditions as Eisenkot and Bennett meet ahead of Sunday talks

Illustration
Government
Qatari envoy Ali al-Thawadi held talks in Tehran, Iranian officials say
Sources and further reading
Every link below was opened and checked when this page was written. Official statements are marked as such: they are the subject's own account, not an independent one.
- Reportingyediotht.meYnet alerts
- Reportingtoitimesofisrael.comThe Times of Israel
- Reportingamitsegalt.meAmit Segal
- Reportingkeshett.meN12
- Reportingkeshett.meN12
How we checked this
The adviser's position was reported by The Times of Israel, Ynet, N12 and journalist Amit Segal, with N12 relaying Segal's account. The claim that Kariv is suspected of leaking a classified document comes from Segal alone and has not been independently verified by us.
Our sourcing and corrections policy →The week from Israel, in one email
The stories that mattered, sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom. Free, weekly, one-click unsubscribe.
One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.
Israel.com is free, and readers like you keep it that way.
The Israel.com newsroom checks every story against its sources and publishes it free. If this one helped, a contribution of any size keeps the next one free too.
One payment, nothing to sign up for. Another amountGive monthly
Latest

File photo

Illustration

File photo

File photo

File photo

Illustration