MK Shira Shapira, a bereaved mother, rebukes minister over forwarded post
The Knesset member, whose son Aner was killed on October 7, said an unnamed minister sent her a post attacking her, and asked what he hoped to achieve.

AI illustration, not a photo of the events.
Shira Shapira, a member of the Knesset, Israel's parliament, has publicly responded to a post that she says a government minister forwarded to her, a post that attacked her in her capacity as a bereaved mother. Ynet reported that Shapira, who sits for the Yashar! party, shared the message herself and did not name the minister who sent it.
Shapira is the mother of Aner Shapira, who was killed on October 7 after, according to Ynet, repeatedly throwing grenades back out of the shelter where he was sheltering. In her response, carried by several Israeli outlets on Sunday morning, she wrote that there is something especially cruel in trying to set a bereaved mother against her fallen son. According to the post as quoted by journalist Amit Segal, she added that when a minister in Israel chooses to pass on such words, "he should ask himself what he sought to achieve."
What the forwarded post said
The reports describe the content of the post differently, and none of them publishes it in full. Ynet's account says the post accused Shapira of standing with people who lend support, literally a "tailwind," to those who murdered her son. Dafna Liel, writing on N12's news channel, described it as claiming Shapira is a partner to tearing the country apart and to favouring Israel's enemies. The two descriptions may reflect different passages of the same text, but the reports do not say so, and neither identifies who originally wrote the post.
All three organisations agree on the central points: the post was forwarded to Shapira by a serving government minister, it targeted her as a bereaved mother, and she chose to make it public herself.
Shapira's response
Segal's channel carried the fullest version of her statement. In it, Shapira said she was not asking to be shielded from criticism because of the tragedy that struck her family, but that there is a limit. She then repeated the line, also quoted by Ynet and N12, about the particular cruelty of placing a grieving mother in opposition to her dead son.
Get an email the day Israel has a new government.
Coalition talks can take weeks. When a government is sworn in, Israel.com's newsroom emails who leads it, which parties are in and who got which ministry, then the Friday email each week. Free, and one click unsubscribes.
One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.
Ynet's report added a rhetorical question from her post, in which she asked how anyone could claim to speak in her son's name. A separate Ynet news alert quoted her as saying that her love for the country, and the price her family paid for it, would not be called into question.
Who Shira Shapira is
Shapira entered public life after the loss of her son. Aner Shapira's name became known in Israel through accounts of his actions inside a migunit, the small concrete roadside shelters common in communities near the Gaza border, designed to protect people caught outdoors during rocket fire. On October 7, when Hamas gunmen crossed into southern Israel, many civilians took refuge in such shelters, and several became sites of mass killing. Ynet's description of Aner Shapira repeatedly hurling grenades out of the shelter reflects the way his story has been told in Israel since.

File photo
Next story Government
Likud sets out its terms for a national unity government with Netanyahu
She now serves as a Knesset member for Yashar!, a party whose name in Hebrew means "straight" or "honest." The reports do not describe the political dispute that prompted the attack on her, beyond the language of the post itself.
Why bereavement carries weight in Israeli politics
In Israel, where military service is compulsory for most Jewish citizens and where many families have lost relatives to war and terror, bereaved parents hold a particular moral standing in public life. Politicians across the spectrum tend to treat them with deference, and invoking the dead to score political points is widely seen as crossing a line. That convention is the backdrop to Shapira's statement. She explicitly separated two things: criticism of her positions as a lawmaker, which she said she accepts, and an attempt to use her son's death against her, which she rejected.
Since October 7, a number of bereaved relatives have entered politics or become prominent activists, on different sides of Israel's political debates. That has made clashes between elected officials and grieving families more frequent, and the question of whether a bereaved parent in politics can be criticised like any other politician has been argued repeatedly.
What the reports do not say
None of the reports names the minister who forwarded the post, and Ynet notes that Shapira herself declined to identify him. No response from the minister or from the government has been reported. The original author of the post is not identified, and the reports give differing summaries of its content without publishing the full text, so it is not clear whether Ynet and N12 are describing the same wording.
People in this story: Aner Shapira, Amit Segal
Read next
All government →
File photo
Government
Likud sets conditions as Eisenkot and Bennett meet ahead of Sunday talks

Illustration
Government
Qatari envoy Ali al-Thawadi held talks in Tehran, Iranian officials say

File photo
Government
Liberman calls minority government a trap, urges coalition with Shas and UTJ

Illustration
Government
Board of Peace adviser warns Gaza 'keys' could go back to the UN
Sources and further reading
Every link below was opened and checked when this page was written. Official statements are marked as such: they are the subject's own account, not an independent one.
- Reportingyediothynet.co.ilYnet
- Reportingyediotht.meYnet alerts
- Reportingamitsegalt.meAmit Segal
- Reportingkeshett.meN12
How we checked this
The event was reported by Ynet, N12 and journalist Amit Segal, all quoting Shapira's own statement. The content of the forwarded post is described differently by Ynet and N12, and the minister's identity is not given in any report.
Our sourcing and corrections policy →The week from Israel, in one email
The stories that mattered, sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom. Free, weekly, one-click unsubscribe.
One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.
Israel.com is free, and readers like you keep it that way.
The Israel.com newsroom checks every story against its sources and publishes it free. If this one helped, a contribution of any size keeps the next one free too.
One payment, nothing to sign up for. Another amountGive monthly
Latest

Illustration

Illustration

Illustration

Illustration

Illustration
File photo · Nick Karvounis / Unsplash