Police pelted with stones in Beit Shemesh after disputed draft arrest
Crowds clashed with police overnight in Beit Shemesh after reports that a Haredi deserter was being detained, and Gadi Eisenkot called for the rioters to be arrested.

AI illustration, not a photo of the events.
Police and Border Police officers were attacked overnight in Beit Shemesh after word spread among ultra-Orthodox residents that a young man being held by officers was a deserter from the army, according to Hebrew-language reports. Ynet reported that the incident began when police stopped a teenager for a check because he had been driving without a licence. Ultra-Orthodox groups that oppose military conscription then claimed he was a deserter being arrested, and dozens of rioters arrived and managed to get the suspect away from the police.
Ynet said reinforced police units and Border Police fighters were sent in, used stun grenades and extracted officers who had been hit by stones. A bag of rubbish was thrown into a police car. News.co.il reported that the disturbances took place in the Rama D neighbourhood and continued even after the man was released a short time later. It also reported that as officers pulled back from the crowd, one officer's personal handgun was pulled out of its holster and fell onto the road while still attached to its security strap. The officer recovered the weapon and the officers left the area unharmed, according to that report.
What the sources posted
המראות הלילה בבית שמש חמורים ביותר וראויים לכל גינוי. אני מגנה בתוקף את המהומה האלימה במהלכה הותקפו שוטרים שמילאו את תפקידם, על ידי המוני חרדים קיצוניים. מדינת ישראל היא מדינת חוק וסדר, בה לובשי מדים אמורים להיות מסוגלים לבצע את תפקידם באופן מלא, בלי שיהיו צריכים חילוץ משטרתי Show more
On the ground
A protest broke out in Beit Shemesh, Israel Police stated, following several haredi (ultra-Orthodox) protests blocking roads in Jerusalem. jpost.com/israel-news/ar…
Protesters clash with police in Beit Shemesh after attempted arrest of Haredi teen timesofisrael.com/liveblog-novem…
What the reports disagree on
The accounts differ on what set off the confrontation and how it ended. Ynet describes a routine traffic stop of a teenage driver, with the deserter claim coming from anti-draft groups, and says rioters freed the suspect from the police. News.co.il describes the trigger as a report of an attempted arrest of a Haredi deserter and says the man was released. Neither account settles whether the person stopped was in fact wanted for desertion.
Eisenkot's response
Gadi Eisenkot, a former chief of staff of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) who is now a politician, condemned the violence. In a post on X, he wrote that the scenes from Beit Shemesh were extremely serious and that he strongly condemned what he described as a violent riot in which crowds of extremist Haredim attacked police officers doing their job. He wrote that Israel is "a state of law and order" in which people in uniform should be able to carry out their duties without needing a police rescue or fearing for their lives, and called on the police and law enforcement to act immediately to arrest the rioters and bring them to justice. N12 carried his statement in its news flashes.
These characterisations of the crowd and of the danger to officers are Eisenkot's own; the news reports describe stones and a rubbish bag being thrown and officers being extracted, and News.co.il says the officers it described left without injury.
Israel's week in five stories, every Friday
Sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom, with Shabbat times. Free, one-click unsubscribe.
One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.
Beit Shemesh and the draft dispute
Beit Shemesh is a city west of Jerusalem with a large Haredi, or ultra-Orthodox, population, and parts of the city have been the scene of previous friction between ultra-Orthodox residents and state authorities. The Border Police, known in Hebrew by the abbreviation Magav, is a paramilitary branch of the Israel Police often deployed to reinforce regular officers during unrest.
Military service is compulsory for most Jewish Israelis, but ultra-Orthodox men have for decades largely avoided it through arrangements allowing full-time religious study. That arrangement has been the subject of prolonged legal and political dispute, and enforcement against young Haredi men who do not report for service has drawn street protests from parts of the community. Some groups actively oppose any enlistment and mobilise quickly when they believe a Haredi man is being detained over the draft. In Israeli usage, a "deserter" in this context generally refers to someone who has been called up and has not reported, rather than a soldier who has left a unit.
What the reports do not say
None of the reports gives a police statement on the incident, a figure for officers hurt or people arrested, or confirmation from the military of whether the young man was listed as a deserter. It is also not reported whether police have opened an investigation into the attack on officers or the handling of the officer's weapon.

Davidbena / CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons
People in this story: Gadi Eisenkot
Read next
All courts & crime →
Illustration
Courts & Crime
Stones and a garbage bag thrown at police cars in Beit Shemesh clash

Illustration
Security
Stun grenades and stones at Haredi protest in Beit Shemesh; bus hits protester

Illustration
Courts & Crime
Police use water cannon as Haredi protests spread to Beit Shemesh

Illustration
Courts & Crime
Beit Hanina man, 19, indicted over alleged attack plan near Temple Mount
Sources and further reading
Every link below was opened and checked when this page was written. Official statements are marked as such: they are the subject's own account, not an independent one.
- Officialeisenkotx.comGadi Eisenkot on X
- Reportingyediothynet.co.ilYnet
- Reportingnewssilt.meNews.co.il
- Reportingkeshett.meN12
How we checked this
The unrest was reported by Ynet and News.co.il, which differ on what triggered it and how the man left police custody; the dropped-weapon detail comes from News.co.il alone. Eisenkot's characterisation of the crowd is his own, from his X post, also carried by N12.
Our sourcing and corrections policy →The week from Israel, in one email
The stories that mattered, sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom. Free, weekly, one-click unsubscribe.
One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.
Latest

Illustration

Illustration

Illustration

Illustration

Illustration

File photo