Skip to main content

Smotrich says Kahana chose 'Muslim Brotherhood over brothers in arms'

The finance minister attacked Matan Kahana, a would-be Knesset speaker, for turning down a Religious Zionism offer, calling reliance on certain votes a red line.

The Israel.com Newsroom··3 min read·
Share
Bezalel Smotrich in 2023

Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, who chairs the Religious Zionism party, accused Matan Kahana of choosing "the Muslim Brotherhood over brothers in arms" after Kahana declined an offer from Smotrich's camp, according to a flash report from Ynet. Ynet said Smotrich made the remarks at his party's faction meeting in the Knesset, Israel's parliament.

The dispute concerns the post of Knesset speaker. The Times of Israel described Kahana as a would-be Knesset speaker and reported that Smotrich said he was choosing "Arabs over Jews." A fuller version of the statement, carried by News.co.il, has Smotrich saying Kahana refused what he called a fair proposal from his side, and arguing that becoming speaker with the votes of people he described as supporters of terror would be illegitimate and a red line.

What Smotrich said

According to the text published by News.co.il, Smotrich set out his criticism as a series of contrasts. He said Kahana had preferred Arabs to Jews, had preferred people who will not condemn Hamas to partners in the war effort, and had preferred the Muslim Brotherhood to his own comrades in arms.

Smotrich also addressed the appointment of the speaker's deputies. In the statement as reported by News.co.il, he said that after the seventh of October it is not possible to appoint deputy speakers who are unwilling to define Hamas as a terrorist organisation. He closed by saying that anyone who crosses the line he described would be remembered with lasting disgrace in the history of the State of Israel.

None of the reports names the lawmakers Smotrich was referring to, and none sets out what the offer to Kahana contained. These characterisations are Smotrich's own; the reports present them as his words and do not independently support them.

Israel's week in five stories, every Friday

Sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom, with Shabbat times. Free, one-click unsubscribe.

One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.

The phrase "brothers in arms"

The Hebrew expression Smotrich used, achim laneshek, translates as "brothers in arms" and refers to people who serve or fight alongside one another. In Israel, where military service is a shared experience for much of the Jewish population, it carries strong emotional weight. Smotrich paired it with the Muslim Brotherhood, using the shared word "brothers" for rhetorical effect.

The Muslim Brotherhood is a transnational Sunni Islamist movement that originated in Egypt. Hamas, the group that rules Gaza and that Israel and many other countries designate as a terrorist organisation, emerged from the movement's Palestinian branch. Smotrich's reference to it is a charge about the political allies he says Kahana is relying on.

Why the speaker's post matters

The Knesset speaker presides over the chamber, controls much of its agenda and procedure, and represents the parliament formally. The speaker is chosen by a vote of the members, so a candidate needs to assemble a majority, which can mean drawing support from across party lines. Deputy speakers are also appointed and take turns chairing sessions.

The reports suggest the contest over the post has become a test of which parties a candidate is willing to rely on. Smotrich's argument, as reported, is that winning the role with the backing of members who will not label Hamas a terrorist group should be ruled out, whatever the arithmetic.

Faction meetings

Israeli parties represented in the Knesset hold regular faction meetings, typically at the start of the parliamentary week. Party leaders often open them with a statement to the press, and these remarks are a common venue for setting out positions on coalition talks and parliamentary appointments. Ynet's report places Smotrich's comments in that setting.

What the reports do not say

None of the reports includes a response from Kahana, and none describes the terms of the offer Smotrich said was rejected. The reports also do not say when the vote for speaker will take place, which parties are backing Kahana, or which lawmakers Smotrich meant when he spoke of supporters of terror and of deputies who will not condemn Hamas.

Topicsknessetsmotrichisraeli politicsreligious zionism

Sources and further reading

Every link below was opened and checked when this page was written. Official statements are marked as such: they are the subject's own account, not an independent one.

  1. Reportingyediotht.me
    Ynet alerts
  2. Reportingnewssilt.me
    News.co.il
  3. Reportingtoitimesofisrael.com
    The Times of Israel

How we checked this

Ynet, News.co.il and The Times of Israel all reported Smotrich's remarks; the fuller text of his statement comes from News.co.il. All characterisations of Kahana and his supporters are Smotrich's own and are not independently verified.

Our sourcing and corrections policy →

The week from Israel, in one email

The stories that mattered, sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom. Free, weekly, one-click unsubscribe.

One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.

Israel.com is free, and readers like you keep it that way.

The Israel.com newsroom checks every story against its sources and publishes it free. If this one helped, a contribution of any size keeps the next one free too.

or

One payment, nothing to sign up for. Another amountGive monthly

Latest

← All news

PartnerAn open partner spot across the News section3,765 Google visits in 28 days. From ₪290 a month.