Skip to main content

Report says IDF sent millions of Palestinian photos to Amazon face scanning

An investigation credited to the Guardian alleges the Israeli military used Amazon's facial recognition on images of Palestinians, some taken at Gaza checkpoints.

The Israel.com Newsroom··3 min read·
Share
Illustration of a quiet aisle of server racks inside a data centre, rows receding under cool even light.

The Israel Defense Forces (IDF), Israel's military, uploaded millions of photographs of Palestinians to Amazon's artificial intelligence face scanning technology, The Times of Israel reported, citing a new investigation. The Jerusalem Post put the number at 3.5 million images, saying they were placed on Amazon servers for facial recognition, and framed the account as a claim made in the report rather than an established fact.

According to Ynet, the Hebrew news site, the investigation was published by the British newspaper the Guardian and carries the bylines of Yuval Abraham and Harry Davies. Ynet said the investigation alleges that part of the image collection was photographed at checkpoints in Gaza at the start of the war, and that the material was passed to Amazon so that the military could run it through the company's face identification system. Ynet described the reporters as filmmakers and said the stated aim was to track Palestinians.

On the ground

Posted by Haaretz on X. Not a source for this article, and not verified by Israel.com.

What the investigation alleges beyond the photos

The claims are not limited to images. Ynet reported that, according to documents cited by the Guardian, the IDF also moved intelligence material and personal information about Palestinians into the company's data centres. Ynet noted that these documents were not displayed in the Guardian's article itself, meaning readers of the original investigation could not inspect them directly.

The three Israeli outlets that carried the story all attributed it to the investigation rather than presenting it as their own reporting. None of the reports available to us describes independent confirmation by an Israeli news organisation.

The organisations involved

The IDF is the military of the State of Israel, covering the army, air force and navy, and it runs intelligence operations through its own units. It has been fighting in Gaza, the coastal Palestinian territory on Israel's southwestern border, since the start of the current war, which is the period the investigation refers to when it says some photos were taken at checkpoints there.

Israel's week in five stories, every Friday

Sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom, with Shabbat times. Free, one-click unsubscribe.

One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.

Amazon, best known internationally as an online retailer, also sells cloud computing: storage space and processing power on its own servers that governments and companies rent instead of running their own hardware. Facial recognition is one of the artificial intelligence services offered through such platforms. It compares a face in one image against a database of other faces to find a likely match, which is why a large collection of photographs is central to how it works.

How the sources differ

The three reports agree on the core allegation: that the IDF transferred photos of Palestinians to Amazon to make use of its facial recognition capability. They differ in detail. The Jerusalem Post alone gives a specific figure of 3.5 million photos, while The Times of Israel and Ynet refer to millions without a precise number. Only Ynet names the Guardian, the two reporters, the Gaza checkpoint origin of some images and the additional transfer of intelligence and personal data. The Jerusalem Post's headline explicitly labels the account as something the report claims.

Why it matters to readers abroad

Questions about the use of commercial technology by militaries, and about the collection of biometric data on civilian populations, have drawn attention from governments, rights groups and technology workers in many countries. An allegation that a major American technology company's tools were used by the Israeli military on Palestinians in Gaza touches on both, and on the wider debate over the conduct of the war.

What the reports do not say

None of the reports we reviewed includes a response from the IDF or from Amazon, so it is not known whether either confirms, disputes or declines to comment on the allegations. The reports do not explain how the 3.5 million figure was arrived at, and the underlying documents were, according to Ynet, not shown in the original article. It is also not stated whether Amazon knew what the images were or how they were being used, or whether the alleged practice is continuing.

Topicsidfgazatechnologysurveillance

Sources and further reading

Every link below was opened and checked when this page was written. Official statements are marked as such: they are the subject's own account, not an independent one.

  1. Reportingtoitimesofisrael.com
    The Times of Israel
  2. Reportingjpostjpost.com
    The Jerusalem Post
  3. Reportingyediothynet.co.il
    Ynet

How we checked this

The Times of Israel, The Jerusalem Post and Ynet all reported the allegation, each attributing it to an investigation; the 3.5 million figure comes only from The Jerusalem Post, and details on the Guardian, the reporters and the data centre transfers come only from Ynet. We have not independently verified the claims, and no response from the IDF or Amazon appears in the reports.

Our sourcing and corrections policy →

The week from Israel, in one email

The stories that mattered, sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom. Free, weekly, one-click unsubscribe.

One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.

Latest

← All news

PartnerAn open partner spot across the News section3,765 Google visits in 28 days. From ₪290 a month.