Skip to main content

Guardian report alleges IDF sent millions of Palestinian photos to Amazon

An investigation co-authored by Yuval Abraham says Israeli military images were moved to Amazon for facial recognition; the underlying documents were not published.

The Israel.com Newsroom··3 min read·
Share
Illustration of a long empty aisle between rows of server racks inside a cloud data centre under cool, even light.

An investigation published by the British newspaper The Guardian alleges that the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) uploaded millions of photographs of Palestinians to cloud servers run by Amazon in order to track them. Israeli news site Ynet reported that the investigation is signed by Yuval Abraham and Harry Davies, and described its authors as filmmakers.

According to Ynet's account of the investigation, some of the images were taken at checkpoints in Gaza in the early stage of the war, and the photographs were transferred to Amazon so that the military could use the company's facial recognition system. Ynet also reported the investigation's claim that the IDF passed intelligence material and personal information about Palestinians to Amazon's data centres. Ynet noted that the documents on which these claims rest were not shown in the article.

On the ground

Posted by Haaretz on X. Not a source for this article, and not verified by Israel.com.

What the investigation alleges

The core allegation, as summarised by Ynet, has three parts. First, that the volume of images was in the millions. Second, that the purpose of moving them onto Amazon's infrastructure was to run them through the company's facial recognition technology and so follow the movements of the people pictured. Third, that the transfer went beyond photographs to include intelligence and personal data stored in the company's data centres.

The detail about Gaza checkpoints matters for readers following the war. Checkpoints are points where people moving through the territory are stopped and inspected by soldiers, and photographing those who pass is one way a military can build a record of who is moving where. The investigation, as Ynet relays it, places some of the photography at such checkpoints at the start of the war, though Ynet's summary does not say how many of the images came from them or where the rest originated.

Who is behind the report

Yuval Abraham is an Israeli journalist and filmmaker; Ynet framed the story around the creators of a film, and Harry Davies is listed alongside him as a co-author of the Guardian piece. The Israel Defense Forces is the country's military, which has been fighting in Gaza since the Hamas-led attack on southern Israel on October 7. Amazon is the US technology company whose cloud division sells computing and storage capacity, along with tools such as image analysis, to governments and businesses.

Israel's week in five stories, every Friday

Sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom, with Shabbat times. Free, one-click unsubscribe.

One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.

An analyst's response

Joe Truzman, a researcher at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD), a think tank, responded on X. Truzman wrote that the Guardian piece raises questions about how the IDF uses Amazon's facial recognition technology, but that it does not answer what he called an important operational question: how much weight a facial match carried when a suspect was identified, and what further evidence had to be gathered before any action followed.

Truzman also described his own work. He wrote that he has used Amazon Rekognition, the company's image and face analysis product, in researching people who took part in the October 7 attack, combining it with other tools and with many hours of corroborating research. In his telling, the software's value lay in helping him check his own assessment of a suspect rather than replacing that assessment. His post is his view as an outside analyst and does not describe IDF practice.

Why facial recognition is contested

The exchange reflects a wider argument over automated identification in conflict. Supporters of such tools say they help investigators sort large amounts of imagery quickly. Critics worry about mass collection of data on civilians and about errors when a computer match is treated as proof. Truzman's question about what other evidence was required goes to that second concern: a match produced by software is a lead, and the investigation, as reported, does not establish how the military treated it.

What the reports do not say

Neither report includes a response from the IDF or from Amazon, so it is not known whether either disputes the allegations. The documents cited by the investigation were not published, according to Ynet, which means the claims about intelligence and personal data cannot yet be checked against the source material. The reports also do not say when the uploading ended, whether it is continuing, what contract or arrangement governed it, or how the identifications were used in practice, the gap Truzman himself highlighted.

Topicsidfgazatechnologysurveillance

Sources and further reading

Every link below was opened and checked when this page was written. Official statements are marked as such: they are the subject's own account, not an independent one.

  1. Reportingyediothynet.co.il
    Ynet
  2. Reportingfddx.com
    Joe Truzman, FDD

How we checked this

The allegations come from a Guardian investigation as summarised by Ynet; we have not seen the underlying documents, which Ynet says were not published. Joe Truzman's comments are his own post on X and are attributed to him alone.

Our sourcing and corrections policy →

The week from Israel, in one email

The stories that mattered, sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom. Free, weekly, one-click unsubscribe.

One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.

Latest

← All news

PartnerAn open partner spot across the News section3,765 Google visits in 28 days. From ₪290 a month.