Netanyahu ends testimony in libel suit as Carmon refuses apology, set to testify
The prime minister finished his evidence against MEMRI head Yigal Carmon, who rejected a second suggestion from the judge to apologise and is due to take the stand.

Benjamin Netanyahu. File photo by Avi Ohayon, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
One update since publication
- Netanyahu's testimony ended; Carmon again refused to apologise and is set to testify. The session was briefly halted for a call.
This story is being added to as it develops. Earlier text is kept below the updates rather than rewritten, so what this page said at each point is still on it.
Update, 17 November, 12:08 Israel time
Netanyahu has finished giving evidence in his defamation suit against MEMRI president Yigal Carmon, and Carmon is now due to take the witness stand himself, N12 correspondent Yael Yaffe reported. According to the same report, the judge put his suggestion of an apology to Carmon a second time once Netanyahu's testimony was over, and Carmon turned it down. Earlier in the hearing it was Carmon's lawyer who had declined the offer.
The testimony was not continuous. News.co.il reported that the session was halted partway through Netanyahu's evidence after the prime minister took a call from his military secretary. The report did not say what the call concerned or how long the break lasted. News.co.il described the suit as concerning publications about alleged receipt of Qatari money and other claims it characterised as false smears.
The Times of Israel framed the case somewhat differently from the earlier reports, describing the allegations at issue as claims that Likud, Netanyahu's party, had taken money from Qatar, rather than the prime minister personally.
None of the new reports say whether Netanyahu was cross-examined by the defence, what Carmon is expected to say from the stand, or why he refused the apology.
The story as first reported
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu took the witness stand in a Jerusalem court on Tuesday in the defamation suit he filed against Yigal Carmon, president of the Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI), and denied that he had ever received money from Qatar. Ynet reported that Netanyahu is seeking half a million shekels in damages and that, early in his testimony, he told the court he had neither acted on Qatar's behalf nor been held captive by it.
Israel's week in five stories, every Friday
Sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom, with Shabbat times. Free, one-click unsubscribe.
One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.
The hearing was an evidentiary session, the stage of an Israeli civil case at which witnesses are heard, according to a Ynet alert sent as Netanyahu arrived at the court. During the session the judge suggested that the defence could end the case by publishing an apology, but Carmon's lawyer declined, N12 reported. Ynet also reported that the offer of an apology was turned down.
What Netanyahu told the court
Both outlets carried versions of the same denial. In a Ynet alert, Netanyahu was quoted saying he had not received "a penny from Qatar" and calling the claim "contemptible". N12 correspondent Yael Yaffe reported that he described the allegation as a "monstrous lie". Ynet's fuller report quoted him saying that those claiming he took Qatari money were lying, and that it had never happened.
Netanyahu also pointed to his own record on Qatar. According to N12, he told the court that he had bombed Qatar and that this was what ultimately led to the decision that brought about the release of the hostages. The reports do not say which action he was referring to or expand on the link he drew between it and the hostage releases. These remarks are his own account given under oath as a plaintiff, and neither outlet reported any response to them from the defence.

File photo
Who Yigal Carmon is
Carmon heads MEMRI, the Middle East Media Research Institute, an organisation known for monitoring and translating media and public statements from the Arab and wider Muslim world into English and other languages. He is a public commentator on Middle Eastern affairs. The reports do not quote the specific statement by Carmon that prompted the lawsuit, nor do they say when or where it was made. Ynet framed the suit as part of the wider dispute over claims about Netanyahu's attitude toward Qatar.
Why Qatar is a sensitive subject in Israel
Qatar, a small Gulf state, has played a central role as a go-between in indirect negotiations between Israel and Hamas over the Gaza war and the hostages taken from Israel. It has also hosted Hamas political leaders. That combination has made any suggestion of Qatari influence over Israeli decision-makers politically charged. Netanyahu's testimony, as reported, was aimed squarely at rejecting the idea that he was compromised by Qatar in any way, personally or politically.
How defamation cases work in Israel
In Hebrew, defamation is known as lashon hara, a term drawn from Jewish religious law that literally means "evil tongue" and refers to harmful speech about another person. Israeli law treats defamation primarily as a civil matter, in which the person who says they were harmed sues for compensation, as Netanyahu has done here. Judges in Israeli civil cases often encourage the parties to settle before or during trial. The judge's suggestion that the case could close with a published apology, which the defence rejected, means the proceedings are set to continue.
Netanyahu is a sitting prime minister appearing in court as a private plaintiff. That is a different role from his position as a defendant in his long-running criminal corruption trial, which is a separate case and was not the subject of Tuesday's hearing.
What the reports do not say
The reports do not set out what Carmon actually said about Netanyahu and Qatar, and they carry no statement from Carmon himself or from his lawyer, identified by N12 as attorney Abai, explaining why the apology offer was refused. They also do not name the judge, say how long Netanyahu's testimony lasted, whether he was cross-examined, or when the next hearing is scheduled. Netanyahu's claim that bombing Qatar led to the release of hostages was reported only as his own statement, without further detail.
Read next
All courts & crime →
File photo
Religion
Netanyahu says any government he forms will include the Haredi parties

Illustration
Courts & Crime
Beit Hanina man, 19, indicted over alleged attack plan near Temple Mount

Illustration
Courts & Crime
Police raid Turkish opposition-aligned channel Sozcu TV, broadcaster says

Illustration
Courts & Crime
Lahav 433 detains 3 in municipal company graft probe, more to be questioned
Sources and further reading
Every link below was opened and checked when this page was written. Official statements are marked as such: they are the subject's own account, not an independent one.
- Reportingyediothynet.co.ilYnet
- Reportingyediotht.meYnet alerts
- Reportingyediotht.meYnet alerts
- Reportingkeshett.meN12
- Reportingkeshett.meN12
- Reportingtoitimesofisrael.comThe Times of Israel
- Reportingnewssilt.meNews.co.il
- Reportingkeshett.meN12
How we checked this
Netanyahu's testimony and the refused apology are reported by both N12 and Ynet; the interruption for the military secretary's call is reported only by News.co.il, and Carmon's upcoming testimony only by N12. The Times of Israel describes the allegations as concerning Likud rather than Netanyahu personally.
Our sourcing and corrections policy →The week from Israel, in one email
The stories that mattered, sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom. Free, weekly, one-click unsubscribe.
One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.
Latest

Illustration

Illustration

Illustration

Illustration

Illustration

Illustration