Skip to main content

Attorney general challenges Shin Bet chief to show evidence on Arab party leaders

Gali Baharav-Miara says no one is questioned without evidence and accuses the Shin Bet of stalling, as Justice Solberg says election results will be published.

The Israel.com Newsroom···5 min read·
Share
Illustration of an empty interview room with a bare table, two vacant chairs and soft daylight from a high window.

2 updates since publication

  1. Attorney general's full statement published; Solberg says election results will be released; Abbas says he will face questioning.The article said none of the politicians had responded; Mansour Abbas has now said he will present himself for questioning.
  2. The attorney general publicly rebuked Shin Bet chief David Zini, accusing him of subverting democratic norms.The article said no public statement from the attorney general had been reported; The Times of Israel now reports she publicly rebuked Zini.

This story was added to as it developed. Earlier text is kept below the updates rather than rewritten, so what this page said at each point is still on it.

Update, 4 November, 04:08 Israel time

The attorney general's full statement has now been published, and Justice Noam Solberg has said the election results will be released as planned. In the statement, relayed by journalist Amit Segal, Gali Baharav-Miara said that, citing what she called erroneous reports, citizens and elected officials cannot be questioned without evidence justifying it, and invited the Shin Bet or anyone else holding such evidence to present it. She added that for two days the agency had not handed its material to the special investigation team set up on Solberg's recommendation with the police and prosecution, which she said was in effect holding up the case.

News.co.il reported that Solberg said the Basic Law requires the results to be published tomorrow and that nobody has authority to withhold them. Segal earlier reported that Zini had gone to Solberg's office arguing that the attorney general was thwarting the investigation.

What the sources posted

Barak Ravid of Axios reported that Zini raised the three leaders' names orally at a meeting with Baharav-Miara and Solberg two days earlier and has filed no formal request to question them. Unnamed officials involved in the probe told him Zini had passed on no evidence about the three and was not cooperating with the special team.

Reactions have followed, Ynet reported:

  • Mansour Abbas said he would present himself for questioning.
  • Gadi Eisenkot warned against abusing office for political considerations.
  • Yair Lapid called Zini a plant; the Joint List said he had gone off the rails.
  • Likud said Baharav-Miara was tying the Shin Bet's hands.

Update, 4 November, 01:07 Israel time

Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara has publicly rebuked Shin Bet chief David Zini over his bid to question the Arab party leaders. The Times of Israel reported that the attorney general accused Zini of subverting democratic norms, describing the criticism as a rare public censure of the head of the security service. The available text of the report does not give her full statement or say how it was delivered.

Israel's week in five stories, every Friday

Sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom, with Shabbat times. Free, one-click unsubscribe.

One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.

Barak Ravid of Axios, relaying the report by i24NEWS correspondent Avishai Grinzaig, wrote that the investigation materials contain no evidence against three of the senior Arab party figures Zini wants to question, naming them as Ahmad Tibi, Mansour Abbas and Sami Abu Shehadeh. Ravid added that, regarding the fourth, unnamed lawmaker, there is information that he received money.

There has still been no reported response from the Shin Bet to the attorney general's criticism, and none from the four politicians.

The story as first reported

The head of Israel's Shin Bet security service, David Zini, is seeking to question four senior politicians from the country's Arab parties as suspects in a case of alleged interference in the Knesset election, according to a report first aired by the Israeli broadcaster i24NEWS and picked up by several other outlets. Those named are Ta'al chairman Ahmad Tibi, Ra'am chairman Mansour Abbas and Balad chairman Sami Abu Shehadeh. The fourth is a senior lawmaker whose identity is barred from publication.

The Times of Israel, citing i24NEWS, reported that Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara has asked to see the evidence before deciding whether to approve the interrogations, and that the Shin Bet has so far handed it over only in the case of the unnamed lawmaker. Ynet carried the report under the framing that it came without evidence being presented for the three named party leaders.

What the Shin Bet and the attorney general do

The Shin Bet, also known as the Israel Security Agency, is the country's domestic security and counterintelligence service. Criminal investigations are normally carried out by the Israel Police. Questioning someone "under caution" means questioning them as a suspect, with a formal warning that what they say may be used against them. According to the reports, the attorney general, who heads the government's legal system and the prosecution, wants the evidence in hand before giving her approval to question sitting members of the Knesset, Israel's parliament.

Who the four politicians are

Tibi leads Ta'al, Abbas leads Ra'am, also known as the United Arab List, and Abu Shehadeh leads Balad. All three are parties drawing their support mainly from Arab citizens of Israel. The Times of Israel noted that Abu Shehadeh was disqualified from standing in last week's election, and described the fourth, unnamed politician as a senior Joint List lawmaker. Other outlets referred to him only as a senior member of the Arab parties.

On that lawmaker, the reports describe a different picture. Journalist Amit Segal, relaying the i24NEWS report, wrote that there is agreement across the board that significant evidence exists against him, and that he is expected to be questioned as a suspect even though he cannot legally be named for now.

The dispute over passing evidence to police

Haaretz reported that Zini is declining to give police the evidence of foreign influence and of money transferred to an Arab Israeli lawmaker, contrary to directives from the election committee. The Times of Israel likewise reported that the Shin Bet has not yet given police the material, although the agency and the police had agreed two days earlier to form a joint team. News.co.il reported that because the material has not been transferred, the investigation itself has not yet started.

The accounts are not identical on this point. The Times of Israel says evidence concerning the unnamed lawmaker has reached the attorney general, while Haaretz says evidence concerning a lawmaker has not been passed to police. The reports do not make clear whether these refer to the same material.

A push to treat the case as a security matter

Ynet linked the report to its own earlier story that Zini wants the election investigation classified as a suspected security offence. According to Ynet, such a classification would let the Shin Bet use broader powers, such as preventing a suspect from meeting a lawyer. The reports do not say whether that request has been accepted.

Segal also described what he called an awkward moment at a meeting where Zini began a sentence saying the agency would ask to question others as well; the available text of his post breaks off before saying who.

Reactions so far

N12 reported that a letter was sent in response to the i24NEWS report, without the available text stating who wrote it or what it said. None of the reports carries a response from Tibi, Abbas, Abu Shehadeh or the unnamed lawmaker.

What the reports do not say

  • What evidence, if any, the Shin Bet holds against Tibi, Abbas and Abu Shehadeh, and why it has not been handed over.
  • Whether the attorney general will approve any of the interrogations, and when.
  • Any public statement from the Shin Bet, the attorney general or the four politicians.
  • The author and content of the letter N12 referred to.
  • What the alleged foreign influence consisted of and where the funds are said to have come from.
Topicsshin betarab partiesknesset electionattorney general

Sources and further reading

Every link below was opened and checked when this page was written. Official statements are marked as such: they are the subject's own account, not an independent one.

  1. Reportingyediothynet.co.il
    Ynet
  2. Reportingyediotht.me
    Ynet alerts
  3. Reportinghaaretzhaaretz.com
    Haaretz
  4. Reportingamitsegalt.me
    Amit Segal
  5. Reportingnewssilt.me
    News.co.il
  6. Reportingtoitimesofisrael.com
    The Times of Israel
  7. Reportingkeshett.me
    N12
  8. Reportingtoitimesofisrael.com
    The Times of Israel
  9. Reportingaxiosx.com
    Barak Ravid, Axios
  10. Reportingyediothynet.co.il
    Ynet
  11. Reportingamitsegalt.me
    Amit Segal
  12. Reportingamitsegalt.me
    Amit Segal
  13. Reportingamitsegalt.me
    Amit Segal
  14. Reportingnewssilt.me
    News.co.il
  15. Reportingaxiosx.com
    Barak Ravid, Axios
  16. Reportingaxiosx.com
    Barak Ravid, Axios
  17. Reportingaxiosx.com
    Barak Ravid, Axios

How we checked this

The attorney general's statement is published in full. Claims that Zini supplied no evidence on the three leaders come from unnamed officials via Axios, and Solberg's remarks are reported by News.co.il and Ynet; the Shin Bet has not publicly responded.

Our sourcing and corrections policy →

The week from Israel, in one email

The stories that mattered, sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom. Free, weekly, one-click unsubscribe.

One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.

Latest

← All news

PartnerAn open partner spot across the News section3,765 Google visits in 28 days. From ₪290 a month.