Trump calls Nobel decision an 'indelible stain' on Norway after Pillay win
Trump kept up his attacks on Navi Pillay's Nobel Peace Prize, saying he returned all Israeli hostages and that US envoys settled eight wars.

Donald Trump. File photo by Daniel Torok, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.
One update since publication
- Reports add Pillay's UN human rights role and a Nuremberg announcement; Trump says he returned all Israeli hostages.
This story was added to as it developed. Earlier text is kept below the updates rather than rewritten, so what this page said at each point is still on it.
Update, 10 October, 17:07 Israel time
Further reporting adds detail on Pillay's background and on how the prize was announced. The Hebrew-language channel Abu Ali Express reported that Pillay is a South African judge who served as the fifth United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, and that the announcement of her award was made in the Nuremberg courtroom in Germany where Nazi leaders were tried for war crimes. The channel said a commission she chaired had declared a year earlier that Israel was committing genocide in Gaza.
Abu Ali Express also published a translated extract of a long post by Trump attacking the award. In it he framed the decision as Pillay receiving the prize ahead of the United States, saying American representatives, himself included, had settled eight wars and achieved much else. The channel did not make clear whether this is the same Truth Social post described earlier by Ynet or a new one.
On the ground
The Nobel Peace Prize was awarded Friday to Navanethem “Navi” Pillay, a leading jurist and former U.N. human rights chief. Upon hearing the news, Pillay joked, “If you clap a little bit more, I may share this prize with Trump.” wapo.st/3UdAbSh
Video from The Washington Post. Tap to play. Nothing from it is shown until you do.
Separately, a later Ynet alert quoted Trump as saying he had returned all of the Israeli hostages and still had not been given the Nobel prize. The alert did not say where he made the remark.
There is still no reported response from Pillay, the Nobel committee, the Norwegian government or the Israeli government.
The story as first reported
United States President Donald Trump has denounced the decision to award this year's Nobel Peace Prize to Navi Pillay, describing it as disgraceful and embarrassing and saying it had marked Norway with what he called an "indelible stain". The Times of Israel reported that he made the remarks at a campaign rally at the Oncenter in Syracuse, New York, on October 9, 2026, only hours after the committee named Pillay as the laureate.
Get an email the day Israel has a new government.
Coalition talks can take weeks. When a government is sworn in, Israel.com's newsroom emails who leads it, which parties are in and who got which ministry, then the Friday email each week. Free, and one click unsubscribes.
One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.
Trump also turned on Pillay herself. At the rally he called her a "mystery person", adding: "I never heard of the person. Nobody did." In a lengthy post on Truth Social, the social network he owns, Ynet reported that he wrote that nobody knew anything about her apart from her hatred of Israel, that he did not know what she had done, and that having settled conflicts in eight wars and brought hostages home, he deserved eight Nobel prizes rather than one. A short Ynet alert summarised the message as Trump calling Norway corrupt.
Who Navi Pillay is
Pillay is a jurist and a former judge of the International Criminal Court (ICC), the permanent international tribunal that prosecutes individuals for crimes such as genocide and war crimes. According to The Times of Israel, she oversaw a United Nations report which found that Israel had committed genocide in Gaza. Ynet likewise described her as a legal figure who had accused Israel of genocide. Israel rejects the genocide accusation, and the choice of Pillay for the prize was therefore always likely to draw attention in Israel and among its supporters abroad.
Trump's argument that the prize had gone to someone defined by hostility to Israel was echoed in Hebrew-language coverage. N12's foreign desk quoted him as saying no one had heard of her, other than the fact that she apparently hates Israel.

File photo
Next story Security
Trump says US does not need an Iran deal, tells Vance to turn to US cities
Why Norway is the target
The Nobel Peace Prize is decided by a committee based in Norway, which is why Trump directed his anger at the country rather than only at the committee members. N12 noted that he said the decision had left a stain on Norway, where the prize committee operates. In his rally remarks, as reported by The Times of Israel, he extended the criticism to the people who made what he called a disgraceful and embarrassing choice.
A long-running grievance
The complaint is not new. The Times of Israel observed that since he returned to the White House in January 2025, Trump has openly sought the award, and that in each year of his presidency he has voiced disappointment at not receiving it. At the rally he listed several conflicts he claims to have played a part in ending, and said he had helped stop wars from breaking out between North and South Korea and between Japan and North Korea, among others.
His reference to returning hostages, reported by Ynet, connects the grievance to the Middle East, where Trump has presented his role in the Gaza conflict as part of his case for the prize. The Jerusalem Post also covered the episode, characterising it as Trump fuming over being passed over for the prize.
Where the accounts differ
The reports place the remarks in different settings. The Times of Israel attributes the "mystery person" and "indelible stain" comments to the Syracuse rally, while Ynet describes a long Truth Social post as the vehicle for his comments about Pillay and his claim to deserve eight prizes. The two may reflect separate statements made on the same day, but the reports do not say so explicitly. The wording attributed to him on Pillay and Israel also varies slightly between outlets, as several of the Hebrew quotations are translations.
What the reports do not say
None of the reports includes a response from the Norwegian government, the Nobel committee or Pillay. They do not give the committee's stated reasons for choosing her, nor do they identify which eight wars Trump counts among those he says he settled, beyond the examples he named at the rally. The reports also do not record any reaction from the Israeli government to either the award or Trump's comments.
Read next
All government →
File photo
Society
Hezbollah chief Qassem says Trump and Netanyahu were defeated at the polls

File photo
Government
Arab party leaders and UTJ in regular contact over Eisenkot bloc talks

Illustration
Government
Hasidic leaders seek signed draft exemption pledges from 48 lawmakers

File photo
Government
Israel bars Mélenchon and Panot; France calls the decision demagogic
Sources and further reading
Every link below was opened and checked when this page was written. Official statements are marked as such: they are the subject's own account, not an independent one.
- Reportingyediothynet.co.ilYnet
- Reportingyediotht.meYnet alerts
- Reportingtoitimesofisrael.comThe Times of Israel
- Reportingtoitimesofisrael.comThe Times of Israel
- Reportingjpostjpost.comThe Jerusalem Post
- Reportingkeshett.meN12
- Reportingkeshett.meN12
- Reportingyediotht.meYnet alerts
- Reportingabualiexpresst.meAbu Ali Express
- Reportingabualiexpresst.meAbu Ali Express
How we checked this
Trump's remarks are reported by several outlets, though wording varies in translation. Pillay's UN role and the Nuremberg announcement venue rest on Abu Ali Express alone so far, and no response from Pillay, Norway or the committee has been reported.
Our sourcing and corrections policy →The week from Israel, in one email
The stories that mattered, sourced and checked by the Israel.com newsroom. Free, weekly, one-click unsubscribe.
One list, unsubscribe in a click. See our privacy policy.
Israel.com is free, and readers like you keep it that way.
The Israel.com newsroom checks every story against its sources and publishes it free. If this one helped, a contribution of any size keeps the next one free too.
One payment, nothing to sign up for. Another amountGive monthly
Latest

Illustration

Illustration

File photo

File photo

Illustration

Illustration